I went with foods that they may have had at the first Thanksgiving. Some of it is a stretch, I know, but work with me. I figure berries and apples, veggies, and 'turkey' were there. Turkey shaped PB&J, pumpkin pie and Ranch dressing...probably not. XD
From L to R - top row: Apple shaped apples and blackberries, popcorn,
pumpkin shaped cucumbers and carrot sticks
bottom row: pumpkin pie with cool whip, turkey shaped pb&j, ranch dressing cup
Hope everyone has a safe and blessed Thanksgiving!